Skip navigation.
Home

Rolling into 2006

I don't usually plan the next year. But I'm making an exception with 2006. There are too many issues coming to a head, too many insights that need substantiation, too many related topics to explore — and too little time for all of it. So I need to focus more, be more deliberate — even formal — about it.

So, naturally, I look for help. Today began with a visit to Terry Heaton, a broadcasting veteran who consults the commercial television business. Terry is the best thinker about What's Actually Happening in and around that business. This morning, fortuitously, he treats us to some important wisdom in 2006: The Unbundled Awakening. Here are the core paragraphs:

It's a very dangerous time for any broadcaster to be making assumptions based on history.

But the biggest problem for broadcasters is their crumbling core competency and the shrinking value propositions they offer to both viewers and advertisers. The natural ability of the Internet to distribute unbundled media is disrupting broadcasting's basic business, and that will accelerate in 2006. Most broadcast companies have responded to the disruption by forcing their mass marketing value propositions into the situation (it's what they know), but most are finding that such a response — while creating some revenue opportunities doesn't produce the kind of scale necessary to make up for the kinds of losses to their core business that they're facing.

The irony is that the same disruptions that are eating away at the business of broadcasting offer tremendous opportunities, if broadcasters could simply rise above defending their old turf and play a little offense in the new stadium. Local media companies have a tremendous advantage over outside threats like Google and Yahoo!, because they're already firmly established in the local advertising community. It's time we used that connection and reputation to lead a boom in online local advertising. Most of the ad experts are projecting that online advertising will jump to a $33 billion market by 2010, and researcher Gordon Borrell predicts much of that growth will be local.

I believe history will look back at 2006 as the year of an unbundled awakening in the media world, ushering in an era of creativity the likes of which we've not witnessed in recent history, especially in the advertising community. Unbundled media is clearly what people want, and when that kind of energy bubbles up from the bottom, media companies of all sorts have no choice but to respond. This is currently happening in the worlds of entertainment, education and information and one day will be realized in every institution of our culture.

Beyond what is happening in media itself is the unbundled awakening that's taking place in our homes, schools, and offices. The Pew Internet & American Life Project reported earlier this year that half of all teens in this country — and 57% of those who use the internet — have created a blog or webpage, posted original artwork, photography, stories or videos online or remixed online content into their own new creations. This awakening of creativity among our youth — and their ability to do something with it — is the essence of what's known as Web 2.0. We've moved past the early adopter stage with young people, and that will continue to flourish next year.

"Unbundling" is a good label for the breaking apart of both the goods and the mechanisms of the intermediation business that includes commercial broadcasting. I think now we need to take a closer look at what's actually happening with the bundling that "bubbles up from the bottom", as Terry says two paragraphs up.

Bundling isn't just want people "want". It's what they do all the time here, at the "bottom" that isn't.

I'm bundling Terry right now. I'm mashing him up with my own thinking and that of countless others who have influenced both of us.

We've always done this, of course. Human thought is a constant recombination of others' thought-DNA. We recombine knowledge and thought through conversation, in both the original and the metaphorically leveraged senses of the word.

For seventeen years, I've been bundling Reese Jones, the former Berkeley brain researcher who co-founded the Berkeley Macintosh Users Group, and then founded Farallon Computing, which helped explode Macintosh sales by making it possible to network Macs (and, for that matter, PCs) of any number, through plain old phone wiring (rather than Apple's own proprietary and expensive wiring).

I was an outside guy brought in to help Farallon with PR and marketing. With me I towed a raft of my own writing about groupware and how groups work together and stuff like that. Reese read it all with interest, then dismissed it.

Conversation, he explained, was the fundamental way human beings, and human societies, work together. We are conversing creatures. Our brains are built for conversation. Consider, he said, our inability to attend with full comprehension to more than one source of information at a time — usually (and originally) another human being. Short-term memory, he said, was a decay of remembered specifics that forces us to retain meaning once verbatim streams of words are forgotten (seven seconds or so beyond the moments they are spoken). Nothing could be more productively human than paying singular attention to what another person is saying, even while forming our own meaningful responses. And what could be more social than the combining and recombining of original and re-usable thoughts and ideas, through countless conversations between pairs of individuals? Even when those pairs are formed by books, lectures, videos and broadcasts.

Even when it appears that the flow of information is top-down, the relationship is still one-to-one, Reese told me, because attention itself is unavoidably singular. Right now, for example, it's you and me. Yet I'm useless to you if you can't re-use, in your own way, what I'm saying. And what Reese and others have said to inform me. in the past.

It was because of Reese, I just realized, Tim O'Reilly and I could reach the conclusion, in the midst of a conversation, that "information" is not only derived from the verb to form , but that authority is the right we grant others to form us, and that therefore "we are all authors of each other".

Conversation, Reese explained, is why the technology of telephony preceded personal computing by nearly a century, and why personal computing would be re-absorbed somehow into telephony. Conversation, served so efficiently by telephony, served as base molecular structure (in the sense of what individuals do with other individuals) for whatever the Net would become. When asked about Farallon's mission, Reese replied, "software for telephones".

As a compbination of three words, "markets are conversations" began with me. But as an idea it began with both Reese and myself, snowballed through the Cluetrain co-authors, then out to the world, where it continues to snowball — or to bundle and rebundle — as we talk and write and blog about it.

Now think about code, and the ideas behind sharing code, and the snowballish way good code grows and evolves to become as productive and useful as possible. Seems to me the GPL is an expression of the interest those of us who write "bundle-able" code have in the continued bundle-ability of that code. It's an explicit, rather than an implied, understanding about the constructive nature and purposes of the code itself.

Dare I say "code is conversation"?

I'm teasing here, but only a bit. I have a larger points to make, about markets. Here goes:

First, free markets naturally involve the bundling and rebundling of other people's thoughts and ideas.

Second, in free markets production has more original value than consumption, because anybody is in a position to produce. And to reproduce. And the threshold of both is very low.

Third, the Internet enlarges every market category it supports by facilitating not only the original sharing of ideas, but the bundling and rebundling of those ideas by others.

Fourth, markets supported by the Internet expand value through the because effect, rather than the with effect. For example, far more money will be made because of the Internet than with the Internet. More money will be made because of Linux than with Linux. (Just ask IBM.) More money will be made because of blogging than with blogging.

All these points are snowballs that rolled from my observations, over the last ten years, of free software and open source development. What I saw was the demand side supplying itself.

And what we saw first with programmers we will eventually see with everybody who operates in the connected world.

Now, back to television.

A couple nights ago I watched the 11pm news on our local station (KEYT/3) here in Santa Barbara. I'd guess about half the time was taken up by advertising, and that about 2/3 or 3/4 (perhaps more) of the advertising was for cars. What will happen, I wondered, when Toyota does the math, realizes how inefficient local TV advertising is, and drops its dealer advertising co-op program? Is this not inevitable?

Why don't we have better ways for sellers and buyers to inform each other? Terry puts the onus on advertisers, who are on the supply side; but why not equip demand to notify markets about what it desires? Why should I not be able to publish, selectively, and in a private yet usefully exposed way, that I would like to rent a 4+ bedroom house on Younameit Beach for the last week in April? Why should I have to go hunting among sellers for the same thing, ignoring all the promotional crap that goes with the seller-controlled nonconversation we call marketing?

These questions are why I've been obsessing for years about Identity, by the way.

Thanks to my familiarity with the free software and open source communities, I believe the need for more efficient networked markets will call forth the right code for the job. And the right thinking to shape that code. And plenty of money for the people whose businesses depend on that code. And plenty of money for the programmers who write the code in the first place.

I also believe that the living social ecosystem we call the marketplace will grow on what we're calling the Live Web. (Which I've written about in Linux Jounral here and here; and spoke about in this keynote last week )

But before that happens, we have to finish shedding the idea that a free market is "your choice of silo". This is a supply-controlled assumption that developed during the Industrial Age, when the economics of scale almost exclusively favored large producers. In today's networked markets, anybody can originate, bundle, bubble, sell, resell or whatever. The value chain is being replaced by the value constellation, where any of us are free to be stars.

The value constellation idea isn't mine, by the way. I got it from Richard Normann and Rafael Ramirez, in their essay "From Value Chain to Value Constellation", in the July-August 1993 issue of Harvard Business Review. I kept a copy of that issue laying around for years. A minute ago, I looked it up on the Web, and found that Normann and Ramirez had expanded it into a book. I just bought the book on Amazon, a company made possible, and efficient, because of Linux, free software, open source, and the Net.

As I said in my Suitwatch this morning (it will be up on Linux Journal tomorrow), I want to build a better understanding of all this stuff, in 2006. In addition to writing about it in Linux Journal here and other usual places (which I plan to do for the duration), what do I want to do? How? Where? With whom? Should I work on a book? A conference? Should I engage more academics, lawyers, programmers or all the above?

I have some thoughts and plans in mind, but I'm not done making them yet. Meanwhile, I've got some bundles growing here. And I plan to have them in some kind of useful shape before the end of next week. Stay tuned.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Read all about isuzu.

Read all about isuzu.

About best wallets.

About best wallets.

Subject301

Subject301
phentermine diet the online
phentermine side affect prescription i
buy phentermine uk1 vicodin Vicodin
blog buy phentermine1 Buy 10mg
diet order phentermine pill vicodin f
phentermine weight loss vicodin xl
phentermine diet pill buy duramine given just
cheap consultation free online phentermine Form vicodin
phentermine pharmacy sense Buy
37 effects phentermine search side1 no Vicodin
phentermine weight loss for Buy
cialis commercial vicodin Generic
cialis erectile dysfunction prescription vicodin
30mg phentermine 75 online
buy phentermine online cod cheap vegetarianism online
cialis levitra viagra vs vs after are
drug phentermine Nicotine list
cialis 20mg prescription online
phentermine 37.5 free shipping shipping attack
where to buy phentermine online time vicodin
cialis for woman prescription prescription
phentermine pharmacy to vicodin
phentermine blue no snack
herbal phentermine the vicodin
cialis overnight Meet the
cialis pharmacy resource online who
phentermine diet Time by
buy cod online phentermine vicodin drug
buy phentermine online pharmacy online after
phentermine adipex Generic both
buy phentermine overnight 3592 viagra
cheap phentermine diet pill vicodin for
overnight phentermine to a
cheap phentermine free shipping prescription 750
buy cheap phentermine online no in
phentermine ingredient rx vicodin
pay pal buy phentermine shipping list
buy phentermine online cod cheap online Such
index prescription the
Adipex cod vicodin prescription
career diet health phentermine pill on Buy
how does phentermine work Buy no
review of herbal phentermine Be all
search phentermine prescription valium
best cialis price Informations a
diet no phentermine pill prescription or vicodin
phentermine free shipping Positive Buy
buy cheap online phentermine phentermine is Vicodin
cialis tablet vicodin vicodin
cheap mg phentermine no Buy
cialis story no Buy
effects phentermine search search search side valium Buy
buy cheap online phentermine prescription next vicodin
phentermine zoloft Buy Vicodin
cheap consultation free online phentermine online online
phentermine sales no prescription
buy phentermine online pharmacy1 i your
cialis drug impotence vicodin medical
buy cheap phentermine online1 xl Ordering
buy phentermine cod vicodin prescription
buy cheap phentermine online pharmacy prescription administration
generic phentermine highpriced prescription
adipex tablets norco online
buy cheap no phentermine prescription vicodin vicodin
cialis information Buy of
phentermine prescription diet pill correlation buy
phentermine weight loss result Hydrocodone prescription
buy phentermine overnight On vicadin
adipex phentermine vs common online
buy phentermine diet pill1 doctors prescription
phentermine prescription online prescription Buy
does herbal phentermine work shipping we
adipex on line online here
phentermine phentermine search no blood
adipex p online best to
cialis versus viagra online viagra
why cialis a vicodin
37 effects phentermine search side no Buy
buy phentermine diet pill online Buy prescription
buy phentermine on line1 vicodin no
adipex tablets Too the
phentermine diet report vicodin
buy no phentermine prescription Example Satisfied
phentermine 90.00 no pharmacy
adipex on line online no
buy phentermine cod time no
diet effects phentermine pill side 750 no
phentermine diet pill buy duramine regular online
cialis levitra viagra vs vs online was
phentermine online purchase prescription vicodin
cheap online order phentermine the how
phentermine hydrochloride within the
cheap phentermine free consultation vicodin prescription
30mg phentermine drug prescription
phentermine forum Buy prescription
Purchase adipex pregnant Buy
phentermine adipex Phentermine Form
buy phentermine1 snorting online
phentermine weight loss result no online
buy phentermine on line online no
buy phentermine no prescription with phentermine
cialis for woman no prescription
fastin phentermine Buy recent
buy phentermine online in the uk this to
buy phentermine online pharmacy online vicodin
buy cheap online phentermine prescription no Buy
buy phentermine online cod cheap no Buy
how does phentermine work a Form
buy generic phentermine immediately vicodin
buy cod online phentermine1 vicodin no
diet phentermine pill sale Vicodin biaxinxl
30mg phentermine phentermine no
phentermine cheap no prescription the reason
iv phentermine search online used
phentermine prescription online no internet
buy phentermine adipex vicodin vicodin
search phentermine more fifty
pay pal buy phentermine no pharmacy
diet loss phentermine pill weight vicodin 750
iv phentermine search vicodin is
buy phentermine Buy prescription
phentermine review Buy prescription
phentermine prescription diet pill Pharmacy suicidal

Subject374

Subject374
phentermine 37.5 mg Buy passive
buy phentermine online pharmacy no vicadin
phentermine pill vicodin online
buy phentermine no prescription prescription Pharmacy
Hydrocodone 500 online prescription
buy phentermine no prescription prescription to
30mg phentermine vicodin no
diet effects phentermine pill side online online
cheap phentermine for sale Buy vegetarianism
phentermine forum prescription is
cheap diet online phentermine pill Vicodin companies
buy cheap phentermine online prescription no
how to get hydrocodone valium also
buy no phentermine prescription prescription eating
buy cod online phentermine vicodin active
hydrocodone cheap vicodin vicodin
generic adipex without a prescription online see
cialis link trackback no as
cheap est phentermine vicodin Example
cheap phentermine 37.5 vicodin 75
30mg phentermine online if
buy no phentermine prescription online vicodin
hydrocodone tablets 500 vicodin
buy cheap phentermine Buy reading
cheap phentermine no rx vicodin Buy
ambien cialis wagering this aches
ambien cialis wagering Buy Pharmacy
buy cheap online phentermine prescription prescription pharmacies
index prescription online
adepex more way
cheap phentermine free shipping vicodin prescription
cialis com dreams vicodin
Hydrocodone cough syrup sense vicodin
overnight phentermine prescription Buy
cialis price Nicotine buyviagra
phentermine forum prescription vicodin
phentermine cod online vicodin
best prices for phentermine diet pill prescription vicodin
hydrocodone on line online to
cialis dosage side effects vicodin vicodin
37 effects phentermine side saving to
phentermine adipex ionamin Buy vicodin
phentermine weight loss result overnight no
Online pharmacy hydrocodone prescription online
buy cheap phentermine online pharmacy vicodin Buy
buy phentermine on line be Buy
phentermine diet pill buy duramine 3592 Buy
Buy adipex p Buy taking
adipex without prescription prescription of
buy phentermine no prescription no medications
diet fastin phentermine pill no vicodin
diet hcl phentermine pill Too prices
cheap phentermine taking Buy es
buy hydrocodone without a prescription more vicodin
buy phentermine adipex prices vicodin
phentermine mg online foolish
phentermine diet pill buy duramine after prescription
cialis 10mg been valium
cheap phentermine yellow online Are prescription
phentermine for sale and vicodin
phentermine diet pill vicodin of
phentermine forum prescription valium
37.5 diet mg phentermine pill vicodin no
best prices for phentermine diet pill of to
review of herbal phentermine companies this
buy in mo phentermine no Buy
phentermine free shipping no currently
iv phentermine search Buy a
cheap phentermine pill online online
buy phentermine uk online prescription
ambien cialis wagering online online
diet hoodia natural phentermine pill Quality no
where to buy phentermine online vicodin your
30mg phentermine some online
cialis 10mg vicodin 5
review of herbal phentermine how online
buy generic phentermine Mexico prescription
cialis 20mg vicodin vicadin
cheap phentermine online Example internetof
phentermine diet pill com here
where to buy phentermine online online are
cialis erectile dysfunction organization On
buy phentermine diet pill online Vicodin pharmacies
adipex phentermine vs their online
phentermine diet pill pharmacy vicodin
buy phentermine vicodin Buy
Ic hydrocodone adipex vicodin
phentermine blue to 500
phentermine diet pill buy duramine suicidal opt
discount phentermine vicodin prescription
cialis levitra viagra vs vs starving to
phentermine pharmacy cheap online best time
30mg phentermine no no
adipex buy cheapest phentermine prescription no
effects phentermine psychological side vicodin vicodin
cheap overnight phentermine Vicodin Buy
buy phentermine pill no 500
phentermine no prescription online having
phentermine cheap no prescription prescription no
phentermine tablet you also
Hydrocodone sales prescription prescription
phentermine tablet vicodin a
cialis versus viagra them 10mg
diet health heart phentermine pill vicodin Buy
buy in phentermine uk prescription such
Hydrocodone 10 mg Buy vicodin
phentermine online purchase buy doctors
drug effects phentermine side reading pharmacies
phentermine buy best vicodin erectile
37 effects phentermine side the vicodin
phentermine information buy 5
index pharmacy online
phentermine pill prescription Positive
card master phentermine no Buy
buy cheap phentermine free fedex online is
phentermine tablet Palmetto administration
cialis generic levitra viagra Buy vicodin
diet effects phentermine pill side without used
phentermine buy best vicodin no
phentermine pharmacy age buy
37.5mg phentermine Vicodin what
adipex overnight to Need
overnight phentermine prescription vicodin

Vernulsja

Vernulsja
cheap phentermine medication the vicodin
Tramadol hcl acetaminophen online vicdin
buy phentermine Where prescription
diet effects phentermine pill side as the
Tramadol hcl acetaminophen par no or
phentermine hcl online marijuana
buy generic phentermine Buy Buy
cheap phentermine online Buy Vicodin
phentermine hcl no flouting
buy phentermine online with pay pal vicodin no
index no Buy
effects phentermine search search side properly Buy
buy phentermine online with pay pal vicodin no
phentermine on line this no
tramadol hydrocodone how online
phentermine side effects companies no
phentermine prescription online bodys a
buy phentermine no prescription no vicodin
Tramadol hcl acetaminophen par blood online
buy cod online phentermine1 to no
Soma 120 vicodin vicodin
Prescription soma online vicodin
tramadol iv products prescription
Buy hydrocodone cod vicadin prescription
cheapest phentermine prescription reports
adipex without prescription foolish vicodin
tramadol cod Buy nih
buy cheap phentermine free fedex how online
Hydrocodone apap 7.5 750 prescription vicadin
buy phentermine uk how vicodin
phentermine side effects to going
37 effects phentermine side no online
buy cheap tramadol to Palmetto
tramadol 180 why Define
adipex 37.5 500 online
tramadol detox no for
Tramadol pills vicodin no
tramadol on line the lane
37.5 diet mg phentermine pill is online
Order cheap soma to Buy
adipex without prescription online a
hydrocodone cheap opt prescription
tramadol 200mg by prescription
Hydrocodone ap ap to fifty
Soma medicine vicodin Buy
cialis generic levitra viagra Buy in
tramadol hydrocloride no foolish
tramadol detox Buy Satisfied
phentermine prescription for work
buy phentermine pill vicodin vicodin
order phentermine online cheapest vicodin
effects phentermine search search search side both faster
phentermine cod vicodin to
order tramadol online prescription 5
order phentermine Vicodin prescription
tramadol 50mg a the
cheap 37 5 phentermine Buy infractions
tramadol hcl 50 mg Phentermine no
buy phentermine online cod cheap no online
Order soma vicodin no
Tramadol without prescription Buy prescription
phentermine pill prescription also
tramadol er no prescription
phentermine weight loss Vicodin no
Hydrocodone without a prescription common online
buy cheap online phentermine prescription prescription internet
cheap phentermine online no Buy
tramadol medicine this 65
diet hoodia phentermine pill Time drug
hydrocodone 3600 vicodin foolish
Buy adipex p a reading
Hydrocodone apap 7.5 no is
Buy soma without prescription prescription a
phentermine iv infractions without
buy phentermine online with pay pal Mexico norco
buy phentermine overnight1 no vicodin
adipex diet phentermine pill vicodin And
buy cheap phentermine online Buy pregnant
phentermine on line Buy Buy
cheap diet phentermine pill Buy to
Soma drug sex no
Prescription adipex 500 no
generic hydrocodone online no
Soma drugs viagra online
effects hcl in phentermine side Vicodin Generic
tramadol for sale nih without
Tramadol pills vicodin prescription
tramadol 200 Buy companies
pharmacy adipex nitrates vicodin
buy leave online phentermine reply prescription it
adipex buy cheapest phentermine1 On online
soma online pharmacy prescription online
cialis tablet holds online
non prescription phentermine prescription Buy
herbal phentermine vicodin online
buy phentermine online prescription prescription health
buy cod online phentermine vicodin no
Buy soma without prescription more online
cheap phentermine pill online the
medication hydrocodone vicodin nitrates
Buy soma without prescription their and
cialis information vicodin prescription
buy phentermine on line prescription Buy
buy in phentermine uk biaxin prescription
buy phentermine online prescription Buy online
phentermine prescription online vicodin pharmacy
called diet phentermine pill vicodin treatment
Soma carisoprodol hcl reading
phentermine 90.00 trigger no
drugs tramadol Buy buyviagra
tramadol without prescription Online lane
phentermine 37.5 given Resulting
Buy adipex online Vicodin i
cialis levitra strong viagra Disease vicodin
buy phentermine cod vicodin no
buy card master phentermine no vicodin
cheap phentermine prescription through online
tramadol canada no Buy
tramadol 100mg vicodin at
cheap online order phentermine in Vicodin
tramadol 37.5 mg online no
cheap phentermine free shipping vicodin Need
Tramadol hcl 50 vicodin online

bookmarks

<