Skip navigation.
Home

Web 2.0, Free Markets and Free Culture

Martin in mediatope offers a cumulative Web 2.0 definition, which he says is Mainly based on the proto-definition work of richard mcmanus' read/write web, still the most important resource for Web 2.0".

At ONLamp, Andy Oram says, The Commons Doesn't Have a Business Plan. He explains,

Once somebody can figure out how to turn a social trend into a moneymaking operation, he or she can raise capital, get a product on the shelves, and collect revenue. A business plan certainly isn't child's play, but at least there's a process in place.

The short answer to that is, The Commons doesn't need a business plan, because it's not a business. It's a place. More importantly, it's the free marketplace where business and culture both happen.

But that's not as obvious at it ought to be. And it won't be, unless we get some clarity about the very different ways we understand and speak about the Net, the Web, and everything that happens on both, especially commerce and culture. Until then too many of us will be talking past each other.

So, since Web 2.0 is a hot concept, let's lock our new understanding to that meme. For that, I propose a goal: Make Web 2.0 the best possible commons for supporting free markets and free culture.

Here's a stab at it.

As I explained in a series of talks (Les Blogs, reboot7, Personal Democracy Forum and Syndicate, to name just four), we understand and speak about the Web in terms of four different metaphors. Those metaphors describe four very different Webs:

  1. When we say we "move" something called "content" through a "medium", addressing or "feeding" or "enclosing" it for "delivery" to "consumers" or "end users", we are saying the Web is a shipping system.
  2. When we "architect," "design," "construct" and "build" things called "sites" with "addresses" and "locations" (sometimes in a "commons") that get "visits" from "traffic," we're saying the Web is real estate.
  3. When we "write" and "author" things called "pages" of "hypertext" that we "post" or "publish" so others can "browse" them, we're saying the Web is a library of journals. Since we tend to group publishing with speech, the Web we talk about here is a place for expression.
  4. When we say we "perform," and we want our "audience" to have an "experience," we are saying the Web is a theater, or a place where entertainment takes place.

Of course these Webs overlap. When we "deliver" an "experience", for example, we combine 1 and 4. When we describe the Web as an "information highway," we combine 1 and 2. Same with "home pages." When we speak or 'cast over the Web, we combine 3 and 4.

All these are Web 1.0 concepts. Remember, Tim Berners-Lee conceived the Web primarily as a publishing system, but built it on a shipping system. TCP/IP was fundamentally about transport, and the moving of packets. The Net is still a vast matrix of flowing packets.

Early in the history of the commercial Web we got the idea that it is a marketplace, and a "space," or a collection of "spaces" (as a synonym for category) we were working with the locational framing of #2.

When we started talking about markets (and other things) as "conversations," we were also working with #2.

Even transportational notions like telephony were more locational than transportional. We go on the Web like we go on the phone. We don't say "Lets go through the phone today." The phone is framed as a place. We talk in places. Even when they're virtual. Distance becomes zero.

In fact, this is how Craig Burton described the Net a long time ago: as a hollow sphere, a three-dimensional zero, comprised entirely of ends: an end-to-end architecture. Or, as David Weinberger and I later described it, a World of Ends.

It is in the interests of Hollywood and the copyright-extention absolutists (of the Sonny Bono school) to frame the Net as a shipping system, and to discredit its end-to-end, peer-to-peer nature. That's why labeling file sharing as "piracy" was such a brilliant move. Pirates attack shipping.

Hollywood doesn't have much of a problem with the locational notion of the Net as a place, as long as it's understood as a place where the Great Distribution Systems, and the First Source Entertianment Empires hold the privileged positions to which they became accustomed before the Net showed up and relocated their businesses to a virtual world they didn't understand.

The two keys are free markets and free speech. These are concepts about which conservatives and progressives agree. They are also essential to the peristence of the Net we love and understand as a place that's built to support both.

That's why I say here that the metaphors we need to unite are 2 and 3: place and publishing.

If we make clear that Web 2.0 is about free markets AND free culture, we'll win a lot more arguments about both.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

bookmarks

Find best isuzu here.

Find best isuzu here.

Wallets here.

Wallets here.

bookmarks

Online Doctor

acetaminophen e hydrocodone
adipex
adipex diet pill
adipex no prescription
adipex online
adipex pill
alprazolam xanax
amoxicillin use
ativan side effects
buy adipex
buy adipex online
buy ambien
buy carisoprodol
buy cheap adipex
buy cheap tramadol
buy cialis
buy drug tramadol
buy fioricet
buy hydrocodone
buy hydrocodone online
buy levitra online
buy meridia
buy propecia
buy soma
buy tramadol
buy ultram
buy valium
buy valium online
buy viagra
buy vicodin
buy xanax
buy xanax online
buy xenical
carisoprodol drug
carisoprodol pill
carisoprodol use
cheap adipex
cheap adipex online
cheap cialis
cheap fioricet
cheap hydrocodone
cheap levitra
cheap phentermine
cheap soma
cheap tramadol
cheap ultram
cheap valium
cheap viagra
cheap xenical
cheapest cialis
cialis
cialis compare levitra viagra
cialis for sale
cialis levitra
cialis levitra viagra
cialis pill
cialis prescription
diet pill xanax
discount cialis
discount phentermine
discount tramadol
discount xenical
fioricet drug
fioricet order
fioricet pill
generic fioricet
generic levitra
generic soma
herbal viagra
hoodia and phentermine
hoodia gordonii
hydrocodone
hydrocodone online
hydrocodone order
hydroxycut
imitrex butalbital
levitra
levitra information
levitra online
levitra online pharmacy
levitra order
liquid cialis
online phentermine
online prescription xanax
order adipex
order cialis
order soma
order tramadol
order valium
order viagra
phentermine
phentermine 37.5
phentermine adipex
phentermine adipex ionamin
phentermine diet pill
phentermine no prescription
phentermine pill
phentermine prescription
prescription soma
prescription xanax
purchase phentermine
purchase tramadol
purchase viagra
soma
soma carisoprodol
soma cod
soma online
soma pill
soma prozac
soma san diego
soma tablet
tenuate
tramadol
tramadol addiction
tramadol cod
tramadol hydrochloride
tramadol online
tramadol opiate
tramadol prescription
tramadol ultram
tramadol withdrawal
ultram
valium
valium online
valium xanax
viagra
viagra alternative
viagra cialis levitra
viagra erection
viagra for women
viagra online
viagra price
viagra sale
viagra tablet
viagra uk
vicodin
vicodin es
vicodin online
vicodin without prescription
wellbutrin xl
withdrawal xanax
xanax
xanax online
xanax valium
xenical
xenical weight loss
zoloft side effects

Online Doctor

Sudden decrease or loss of hearing has been rarely reported in people
taking PDE5 inhibitors, including VIAGRA. It is not possible to determine
whether these events are related directly to the PDE5 inhibitors or to other
factors. If you experience sudden decrease or loss of hearing, stop taking
VIAGRA and contact a doctor right away.
adipex no prescription
amoxicillin use
ativan side effects
buy cialis
buy fioricet
buy hydrocodone
buy meridia
buy propecia
buy soma
buy tramadol
buy ultram
buy valium
buy viagra
buy vicodin
buy xanax
buy xanax online
buy xenical
cheap hydrocodone
cheap levitra
cheap phentermine
cheap tramadol
cheap valium
cheap xenical
generic soma
herbal viagra
hoodia gordonii
hydrocodone online
hydrocodone order
hydroxycut
imitrex butalbital
online phentermine
phentermine no prescription
tenuate
tramadol online
wellbutrin xl
xanax online
zoloft side effects
Have UK you can buy viagra, Blue Pill, herbal viagra and cheap viagra
at the lowest prices in the UK. The Blue Pill is our best selling herbal viagra
and yet still the cheapest viagra on the market! Unlike viagra no prescription
is required to: buy viagra, blue pill, cheap viagra and herbal viagra. The Blue
Pill takes effect in 30 minutes or less and can last up to 4 hours. Buy viagra
online at discount prices and enjoy the many other benefits we offer!

My doctor says...

Sudden decrease or loss of hearing has been rarely reported in people
taking PDE5 inhibitors, including VIAGRA. It is not possible to determine
whether these events are related directly to the PDE5 inhibitors or to other
factors. If you experience sudden decrease or loss of hearing, stop taking
VIAGRA and contact a doctor right away.
cheap soma
buy cheap tramadol
buy tramadol
carisoprodol pill
liquid cialis
buy soma
viagra erection
liquid cialis
soma cod
tramadol cod
buy viagra
generic fioricet
discount tramadol
order cialis
buy ambien
cialis levitra
tramadol cod
carisoprodol use
order cialis
soma online
liquid cialis
carisoprodol pill
fioricet drug
fioricet pill
buy viagra
tramadol cod
carisoprodol drug
fioricet pill
carisoprodol drug
fioricet pill
soma cod
cialis levitra
buy ambien
liquid cialis
cialis levitra
buy carisoprodol
herbal viagra
Have UK you can buy viagra, Blue Pill, herbal viagra and cheap viagra
at the lowest prices in the UK. The Blue Pill is our best selling herbal viagra
and yet still the cheapest viagra on the market! Unlike viagra no prescription
is required to: buy viagra, blue pill, cheap viagra and herbal viagra. The Blue
Pill takes effect in 30 minutes or less and can last up to 4 hours. Buy viagra
online at discount prices and enjoy the many other benefits we offer!

My doctor says...

Sudden decrease or loss of hearing has been rarely reported in people
taking PDE5 inhibitors, including VIAGRA. It is not possible to determine
whether these events are related directly to the PDE5 inhibitors or to other
factors. If you experience sudden decrease or loss of hearing, stop taking
VIAGRA and contact a doctor right away.
viagra erection
cheap cialis